ATLGuide
The Peach Cobbler Power Rankings
We're available to judge your church bakeoff too.
photo credit: Amy Sinclair
Since Georgia is The Peach State and damn near every street in Atlanta has peach in the name, it’s only right that we have a guide devoted to our most famous dessert. We spooned our way through a disturbing amount of peach cobblers so we could discover who came out on top. Some places must’ve forgotten the seasoning. Others went a little too hard with the sugar. And some, we had to put out an A.P.B. to even find a single peach. But eventually we found peach cobbler perfection at these top venues.
NONE
1-5
6s
7s
8s
9s
Unrated: Restaurants we want to re-visit before assigning a rating. We only rate spots where you can eat a full meal. We won’t rate a coffee shop, bar that only serves peanuts, or dessert shop.
THE SPOTS
While the presentation of Ivy’s Heavenly Cobbler, a counter service spot in Grant Park is cute—it comes in a cross between a cupcake wrapper and a personal pie pan—it’s the least interesting thing about them. The crust is buttery, rich, dense yet still flakier than Atlanta weather. As tempting as it is to just focus there, don’t. The peaches in this cobbler are plump and sweet, and the spice-blend-to-sugar ratio is perfect.
photo credit: Amy Sinclair
Busy Bee in the West End is known for its fried chicken, but a close second would have to be its peach cobbler. Here’s the thing: it’s packed with cinnamon and cloves. So if you’re not into spice-rich cobbler, this one isn’t for you. But the warm spices give this dessert more layers and cut through the sweetness, so it's a winner in our book. The cobbler serving is big enough to split, but you might start getting territorial when you’re down to the last few bites.
photo credit: Amy Sinclair
8.0
There’s a reason the Peach Cobbler Cafe has multiple locations in Atlanta—because you can pop in and out for a soul food plate filled with delicious homestyle classics. But are you really doing it right if you don’t order the restaurant’s namesake dish? The peaches are juicy and a touch of cinnamon adds some warm spicy flavor without overpowering the dish. The dough is heavy enough to hold the dessert together, but it’s not so dense that you’re chewing for an eternity.
photo credit: Amy Sinclair
photo credit: Amy Sinclair
7.7
Mark your calendar for peach season, when this Southern fine dining staple in Vinings returns its cobbler to the menu. The peaches taste tart, which contrasts with the sweet, cake-like crust and frozen yogurt. As if that wasn’t enough, Canoe adds puffed rice cereal for some fun crunch. The dessert is small and light, so you’ll be ready for another glass of wine and an after-dinner stroll along the riverside gardens.
RESERVE A TABLE WITH
photo credit: Sarah Newman
photo credit: Sarah Newman
8.2
You’re obviously heading to AB Cookie Company in Municipal Market for their incredible chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, and whatever other flavored cookies they have available that day. But this place has other baked goods on lock, including their peach cobbler. You get a huge chunk with a soft, buttery crust and juicy, plump peaches coated in a comforting mix of cinnamon, nutmeg, and warm spices.
photo credit: Jacinta Howard
Yes, Paschal’s was once a gathering spot for Civil Rights activists like MLK, John Lewis, and Andrew Young. These days, you’ll see business folks and families hanging out at the huge two-level restaurant in the West End, but one thing has been as dependable as Atlanta traffic after 3 pm—their delicious cobbler. It's made with sweet, tender peaches and topped with a gooey, perfectly salty crust.
RESERVE A TABLE WITH
photo credit: Mhandy Gerard
7.9
Lickety Split’s peach cobbler tastes very fresh—like they rounded up peaches from some orchard out back. It’s sweet but not overly so, and comes with a soft, bready crust that's lightly dusted with sugar crystals. The peaches are soft but not mushy, and aren’t overloaded with spices, so the fruit gets a chance to shine. It perfectly caps off the hearty Southern meals that this spot excels at.
photo credit: Amy Sinclair
8.2
Sweet Red Peach’s cobbler is made with peaches that taste fresh—and the baked peaches still keep their texture, so you’re not chewing unidentifiable goop. And the doughy crust is so generous it spills out of the pan, so dough lovers will like this one. It’s a big portion, so it’s ideal for sharing after you’ve hit up the food stalls at Lee + White Food Hall. Just get here right when they open because they sell out fast.
photo credit: Nina Reeder
7.5
Mary Mac’s Tea Room
Yes, this Southern food classic on Ponce is a meat-and-two experience worth checking off your Atlanta list.
Juli Horsford
Staff Writer, Atlanta
Juli has lived in Atlanta since 2015. When she's not writing, she's watching old movies and trying to keep her taco obsession under control.
Nina Reeder
Senior Editor, Atlanta
Nina is a journalist with bylines at places like AJC, Essence, Marriott, etc. She loves cheese and thinks she'd be great at hobby horse.
Jacinta Howard
Senior Staff Writer, Atlanta
Jacinta is a journalist and author, with bylines in Eater and the AJC. She’s fluent in beach, old fashioneds, and classic hip-hop.